While there have not been any ghost sightings at this lighthouse its eerie location earns it a place on this list. This is partly due to the many shipwrecks and drownings that have happened around the island.

The 20 Most Terrifyingly Haunted Lighthouses In The U S A
Perhaps the resident phantom feels safe here since the sturdy building with the light on top survived the 1964 tsunami that destroyed much of crescent city.